Approved Pro
Approved Pro

Cream City Appraisals, LLC

Appraisal Real Estate Service,

About us

Cream City Appraisals, LLC, is committed to excellence, in every aspect of our business. We uphold a standard of integrity, bound by fairness, honesty and personal responsibility. Our distinction, is the quality of service we bring to our customers. Accurate knowledge of our trade combined with ability, is what makes us true professionals. Above all, we are watchful of our customers interests and make their concerns the basis of our business. Please give us a call today!

Business highlights

25 years of experience

Amenities

Free Estimates

Yes

Accepted Payment Methods

  • CreditCard
Reviews
4.573 Reviews
Number of StarsImage of DistributionNumber of Ratings
5
82%
4
10%
3
0%
2
0%
1
8%

Filter reviews by service

Showing 1-25 of 73 reviews
David B.
Oct 2022
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
$35,000
Joe was fast with his communication and service in addition to being very fair and transparent with how he came to his appraisal value. Very nice to work with and refreshingly honest with the work done!

Lloyd B.
Jun 2022
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
Great person, went above and beyond to help me!

Steve C.
May 2022
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
$35,000
Joe visited promptly and was very professional. He provided the appraisal in a timely manner.

Amelia O.
Nov 2021
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
very caring individual . Iâ m going thru a very bad time and Joe was great ! thank you Joe

Mark M.
Oct 2021
4.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
Friendly to work with.

Amanda H.
Jul 2021
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
Joe was friendly, efficient and had excellent communication. I felt comfortable with him in my home.

Paul S.
Feb 2021
0.5
Appraisal Real Estate Service
I talked to Joe of Cream City Appraisals and found him knowledgeable and easy to work with. He said he would get back in 3or 4 days. It has been 3 or 4 weeks and I have not heard from him. Repeated phone calls indicated his message box was full, I finally was able to leave a message but have not got a call back.

Lamel W.
Jan 2021
4.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
They need to be more responsive and reach out with the full information instead of putting their customers off and interact more with their customers.

Kurt V.
Jan 2021
4.5
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
Professional and kind.

Bonnie W.
Nov 2020
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
Awesome job!

Raymond C.
Nov 2020
4.5
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
He was on time

Patrick H.
Nov 2020
0.5
Appraisal Real Estate Service
See comments above.

Paul Z.
Sep 2020
0.5
Appraisal Real Estate Service
The guy came out. Measured the property, and never produced an appraisal despite numerous requests.
Response from

"Paul, I did complete inspection last year. Your property is for a 4 family that is in need of significant repair. There is so much potential for the property, however in its condition like it was last year, there was very little market support for its condition. There was a highest and best use issue. I put request into city regarding possibility of splitting parcel. I never heard from you after we had conversations. I assumed that you did not need report, and did not want to charge you for something you could not use. Best of luck, I am sorry about miscommunication."


Mary Jo G.
Jul 2020
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
This is the second time I have used Cream City Appraisals. Very professional and knowledgeable. Did take some time to receive fnial product but that was because Joe was waiting on the sale of a property that he wanted to include in the comparables. Highly recommend.

Ramy A.
Jul 2020
4.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
$15,000
I hired him to do an appraisal while my house was on the market for sale just to get a feeling of the market and prices for similar homes around me. I know that you never get the same appraisal from two different people. It does depend on a lot, and I do understand this, but the issue that after I hired him, he told me that he could not complete the appraisals because I overpaid when I bought this house and my house no way get the asking price. He refuses to complete the report, and honestly, he did not charge me and refused to take money or give me the appraisal, but I still paid him 150$ for his time and effort for going to the house and take pictures and all that beautiful jazz!! Anyway, he sent me an unusable report almost empty after I sent him the 150$, and at is completed empty with incorrect information about my house as well! I sold the home over asking price by 10k. The issue is when you hire someone, you expect you get the job done whatever the result it is. My two cents he is nice, but he wasted my time and did even did the job he was hired to do whatever the result of the report it is he should complete the job. Honestly, because of him, I accept the first offer I got. This is my story and its your call to hire him or not, but I had to share my experience with this company.
Response from

"Ramy purchased a duplex for $261,000 in 2017. Per MLS photos he did no significant updates since the purchase in 2017. He purchased the property for $261,000 in 2017. He currently has the property on the market for $324,00. He wanted my appraisal for marketing purposes to support the list price. I have been appraising for 15 years and have done a significant amount of work in Bay View where the property is located. There were no sales that supported his list price. I had expected to update when I inspected the property to justify the increase in value. After I inspected the property and found no updates to justify the increase in value, I called Ramy and told him I could not help him accomplish his goals, and I would not fraudulently inflate the value of his property. He was very mad, and I told him there was no charge, I didn't want his money if I couldn't help him accomplish what he wanted. He was insistent on paying me and told me to send what I had. After I sent him what I had, all he did was tell me how poor a job I did. Unfortunately, he wrote this review before he sold the property. The property is under contract but has not closed. I hope he gets his list price, there are no sales to support it. Maybe the buyer is a cash buyer and might not need an appraisal. I tried to be honest, and that is why I did not complete the report. I felt I would be completing a report just to take his money, and I am not out for a quick money grab. I take pride in my work, and will not be a part of a seller trying to fraudulently support an inflated listing price."


Susan B.
May 2020
3.5
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
Great job! Very kind and courteous. On time for the appraisal. Took a long time to get the report

Tim E.
May 2020
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
Very pleasant, professional and personal approach. Joe didn't look to make things any more complicated than they needed to be. Just came in and got the job done.

Jeffrey S.
May 2020
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
$32,500
This Appraiser was a real pro. Went the extra mile to research all comparable sales and went back to capture a very recent sale that was not part of his original search. That made a big difference in enhancing the value of the appraisal that I was paying him for.

Glenn K.
Apr 2020
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
Joe was absolutely fantastic. Our situation was timely and he was able to come out right away. He was professional, knowledgeable and personable. He answered all of my questions and had some great recommendations too. He delivered the appraisal right on time despite there being a death in his family the previous day. I highly recommend him.

Jeanne K.
Apr 2020
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
$30,000
Joe is personable and helpful.

Lori I.
Mar 2020
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
Joe delivers excellent service.

Debra L.
Mar 2020
4.5
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro

Brian K.
Mar 2020
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
$30,000
Joe was fast, friendly and professional... I was very happy with the final appraisal... I would highly recommend...

Glenn K.
Feb 2020
5.0
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
Joe was fantastic. Professional, nice and fast. I would definitely use him again.

Joseph W.
Jan 2020
4.5
Appraisal Real Estate Service
Yes, I recommend this pro
Report was well done and thorugh.
Showing 1-25 of 73

Licensing

Licensed*

Trade License Number

1918-4

Trade License Expiration

12/14/2025

State Contractor License Requirements

All statements concerning insurance, licenses, and bonds are informational only, and are self-reported. Since insurance, licenses and bonds can expire and can be cancelled, homeowners should always check such information for themselves. To find more licensing information for your state, visit our Find Licensing Requirements page.

*Contact business to see additional licenses.

FAQ

Cream City Appraisals, LLC is currently rated 4.5 overall out of 5.
Cream City Appraisals, LLC accepts the following forms of payment: CreditCard
Yes, Cream City Appraisals, LLC offers free project estimates.
No, Cream City Appraisals, LLC does not offer eco-friendly accreditations.
No, Cream City Appraisals, LLC does not offer a senior discount.
No, Cream City Appraisals, LLC does not offer emergency services.
No, Cream City Appraisals, LLC does not offer warranties.

Contact Information

Share project details to get started.